The Still-No-Coach Debate
With no end to the confusing, befuddling and bundled Redskins coaching search in sight, Times beat reporter Ryan O'Halloran and NBC 4's Lindsay Czarniak try to figure out what the heck went wrong with the Gregg Williams interview, what Joe Gibbs is thinking and also give a Super Bowl prediction.
1. Just a few weeks ago, after Joe Gibbs' retirement, the natural assumption was that Gregg Williams would be promoted to head coach, Al Saunders would likely to stay on to run the offense and stability would rule. What the heck happened?
Ryan: Danny and Vinny couldn't help themselves. Gibbs, by all accounts, recommended Williams as his successor -- a plan Coach Joe had in his idea for at least two years, since Williams spurned several head-coaching opportunities to stay with the Redskins. But something happened during the Williams-Snyder-Cerrato conversations. Our guess -- Williams (who showed zero respect for several media outlets -- The Washington Times and Channel 4 included -- by speaking to only two media outlets on Friday) asked Snyder to can Vinny. That wasn't going to happen. When the Redskins interviewed Jim Mora, it was a sign they had soured on Williams; when they promoted Cerrato, it was over.
Lindsay: I know Gregg really wanted the job, which may seem obvious, but I think it's important because it demonstrates the fact that he didn't take the opportunity lightly. However, my guess is that Dan Snyder and Vinny weren't willing to give the kind of personnel control that Gregg wanted to make the team successful. I believe that's where the difference occurred. Williams is not the type to go and say derogatory things about Coach Gibbs and about Vinny Cerrato but he is the kind of guy that stands up for what he really believes and he knows how this team responds. We saw that based on how he himself took a small step back and allowed players to have more control this season. It worked and like Ryan said, there was something that the sides couldn't agree upon. When his aggression toward Gibbs was questioned, Williams was done.
2. Joe Gibbs has to be slightly upset about the way things have gone down. If you gave Joe some truth syrup, what questions would you like to have him answer?
Ryan: The Danny must be giving Car Owner Joe a ton of money (several millions) to be the good solider until the very end. Most of Joe's four years of work have gone down the tubes. I hope Gibbs is ticked. I hope he will rip The Danny & Vinny Show when we chat next month in Daytona. But I doubt that will happen on the record. My questions: Did you strongly recommend Gregg? Would have stayed for a fifth year if you got the hint Gregg wasn't their guy? How much will this hurt Jason Campbell's progress? Will you cut ties with the team after this turn of events?
Lindsay: Great question. I would want to know who he recommended and in what order to Dan and Vinny. How he feels watching what was built over this last season fall into a completely unorganized situation and what kind of advice Snyder has called him for after he stepped down? I would have to follow up the conversation with the question ... why Toyota?
3. The Redskins have made it a tradition to re-work players' deals in order to free up cap space. With this upheaval, how much does that hurt their efforts?
Ryan: On defense, some guys may be willing to re-work their deals because the transition to Greg Blache should be relatively seamless. Guys like Phillip Daniels and Cornelius Griffin will move around some money because of the respect they have for Blache. MLB Marcus Washington was a big-time Williams Supporter and that will be interesting to monitor. Williams not getting the job all but guarantees that CB Shawn Springs will exit.
Lindsay: Big time. Players are hurt and frustrated and I would guess right now, re-working deals is not looked upon favorably considering how upside down things look for the Redskins right now. I can't see Clinton Portis being a big fan of reworking under this transition. I agree with Ryan, it helps that Blache has a loyal following. I think if you ask any of them right now, the answer is drastically different within the next couple months after dust has settled. I believe there is more frustration than people realize amongst the team.
4. Who should get the job: Fassel, Spagnuolo, Mariucci, Meeks, mystery candidate? Who does Danny/Vinny pick?
Ryan: Of that group, I'll pick Jim Fassel because all things point to his hiring. He has NFL head coaching experience. He's experienced success. He knows the NFC East. And he knows quarterbacks. Fassel would leave Blache to handle the defense and make Campbell's development his primary responsibility. But trying to get inside the cranium of Danny/Vinny not causes a headache, it creates a ton of indecision. I think they go with Fassel.
Lindsay: My head hurts from thinking about this. But here's my thought -- I think they want to hire Fassel. Everything about it makes sense because of what they've chosen, being that Fassel is the one that brought Zorn to their attention and he obviously is comfortable with Blache, but, I'm going with Mariucci. I think there could be too many connections to him, to his west coast ways, to players that are excited about the fact of playing for him. This is a name that Snyder will get a significant splash with. My choice, would be Spagnuolo -- I like what he's done these past few weeks, he's worked a depleted secondary into a playoff contending team that's about to play in the Super Bowl.
5. Whoever the new coach is, should Redskins drop their expectations significantly?
Ryan: No they shouldn't. The Redskins are like a lot of other teams in the league -- average. Al Saunders' departure means there won't be a quarterback competition -- Campbell is the guy and that will only help him. The defense will have many of the same pieces back but it's unclear how Carlos Rogers and Rocky McIntosh will bounce back from their knee injuries. The schedule -- playing the NFC West and the AFC North -- is favorable.
Lindsay: No, I don't think so, either. The deal is that it was the team, the players that found a chemistry at the end of last season and if this team is not shaken up too badly as far as the guys on the field, I think they can pull some of that forward. I think Saunders new job means its very likely Collins could follow him. I expect Zorn to be a benefit to working with Jason but I do worry about how quickly the Skins will adjust to the west coast offense.
6 BONUS: Who wins Sunday's Super Bowl?
Ryan: It's tough to pick against the Patriots so I won't. As the week goes on and the point spread plummets into single digits, the Giants will gain more and more momentum because they're the underdog. But New England is the better team, period. The Patriots will score whenever it's required and win 34-20.
Lindsay: I have jumped on the Eli bandwagon because I want to see him bust past the rep of Peyton's scrappy little brother. I am impressed with how consistent he's become towards the end of the season and the way he says he has learned his lesson in not listening to the criticism Still, I don't see anyway that the Giants can beat New England. I say Patriots 37-24.